Little Snitch vs LuLu: which Mac firewall suits you
In short: Choose LuLu if you want a free, open-source firewall and don't mind answering alerts. Choose Little Snitch if you want the most control and insight a Mac firewall offers, and will pay 59 € for it. If you want neither alerts nor rule-making, look at a list-based firewall such as Ranger instead.
Both are good tools with long histories, and both do the job the built-in macOS firewall doesn't: they watch what your apps send out. We make Ranger, a third option, so take our view with that in mind. Everything below about Little Snitch and LuLu comes from their makers' own pages, linked in each section.
What they have in common
Little Snitch and LuLu are outgoing firewalls. Each sits between your apps and the network and decides whether a connection may leave your Mac. By default both work the same way: when an app connects somewhere new, an alert appears, you click Allow or Deny, and your answer becomes a rule.
Both have a quieter mode for when the alerts get too much, and both let you keep separate sets of rules, called profiles, for different places.
The differences are in depth, price and who they are built for.
LuLu: free, open source, focused
LuLu is made by Objective-See, a non-profit security project, and costs nothing. Its source code is public. At the time of writing the current version is 4.5.7, and it runs on macOS 10.15 or later.
Its alerts are where it shines. Each one names the program and where it wants to go, and lets you check who signed the program, which process started it, and what VirusTotal makes of the file. By default your answer applies to the whole program; you can narrow it to one destination or make it expire after a time.
Since version 4 it has profiles. Its passive mode runs silently and applies the rules you already have. You can also give it an allow list and a block list, either a file on your Mac or a web address that it reloads once a day.
One limit is worth knowing. LuLu's documentation says that blocking by host name only works for connections made through Apple's own networking frameworks. For browsers such as Chrome that do their own networking, LuLu can only block by IP address. Safari and Firefox are not affected.
LuLu suits you if you want a free, transparent tool, like seeing every new connection, and are comfortable judging which ones to allow.
Little Snitch: the deepest, and paid
Little Snitch by Objective Development has been around for more than 20 years, and it shows in the breadth.
Besides alerts it has Silent Mode, which lets new connections through at first so you can decide later at your leisure. It comes with curated blocklists, updated daily, including lists of IP addresses. It encrypts your DNS lookups (the step where your Mac asks which server belongs to a name) through services such as Quad9. Its traffic chart reaches back up to twelve months, its rules can be as narrow as one server and port, and profiles can switch automatically when you join a known Wi-Fi network. There is a command-line tool for people who script things.
A single licence costs 59 €, and there are family and multi-user licences (shop). The licence covers both Little Snitch 6 and the coming Little Snitch 7, which is in beta. If you only want to watch, Little Snitch Mini on the Mac App Store shows connections for free and sells blocking as an in-app purchase.
Little Snitch suits you if you want to understand and control your Mac's network in detail, and will spend time on rules.
Side by side
| LuLu | Little Snitch | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Free | 59 € single licence |
| Source code | Open | Closed |
| When an app connects somewhere new | Alert | Alert, or allowed silently in Silent Mode |
| Quiet mode | Passive mode | Silent Mode |
| Blocklists | Your own, from a file or web address | Curated, updated daily, or your own |
| Watching traffic | Current connections, in its bundled Netiquette monitor | Chart and history up to 12 months |
| Profiles | Yes | Yes, with automatic switching |
If you want neither alerts nor rules
Both tools assume that you want to make decisions. Plenty of people don't, and that is not a failing. An alert asking whether a helper process you have never heard of may reach an address you don't recognise is a hard question for anyone who isn't a network engineer, and a firewall nobody understands tends to get switched off.
Ranger takes the other route. You switch on protection once, as three plain choices: known scam and malware sites, ads and trackers, and Apple's usage reports. Ranger compares every connection from every app with lists that are kept by the HaGeZi and OISD projects and updated daily, stops what matches, and asks nothing. Everything is written down, so you can look at any app, see where it went and switch it off. Profiles and a Block Everything mode are there for when you need them.
It costs €29 once for one Mac, or €49 for up to five Macs in a household, and the 14-day trial needs no email or card.
If you want to approve every connection as it happens, Little Snitch or LuLu will suit you better, and we would rather say so here than lose your trust later. If you would rather have the protection without the questions, try Ranger. For a wider list, including the cheaper and more specialised tools, see the best firewall for your Mac.